Few names freeze the bloodstream of true-crime readers like The Zodiac Killer. A phantom who taunted police, mailed coded threats, hunted couples in the dark, and fed on fear, he became one of the most chilling unresolved serial murder cases in American history. Decades later, the question still claws at us: Who was he?

Below is a clean, compelling timeline of each attack — the verified facts, the misleading rumors, the genuine evidence, and the impact this killer left on survivors, investigators, and an entire nation.

The Timeline of the Zodiac Killer

Lake Herman Road — December 20, 1968

Victims: David Faraday (17), Betty Lou Jensen (16)
Location: Benicia, California
The Crime:
The young couple was parked along Lake Herman Road when someone walked up and opened fire. Betty Lou ran but collapsed under a barrage of bullets. David died beside the Rambler.
Evidence:

• .22-caliber bullets and shell casings
• Tire tracks suggesting the killer parked behind the Rambler
• No witnesses, no warning, no message afterward
  Rumor vs. Fact:
• Rumor: Zodiac confessed in a later letter.
• Fact: He claimed responsibility but provided no verifiable detail linking him conclusively to this attack.
  Impact:
  This wasn’t just a double homicide — it was the spark that ignited Northern California’s darkest legend.

Blue Rock Springs — July 4, 1969

Victims: Darlene Ferrin (22), Michael Mageau (19, survived)
Location: Vallejo, California
The Crime:
A vehicle pulled up, left, then returned. The killer approached and unleashed a rapid series of gunshots before calmly walking back to his car.
Evidence:

• 9mm Luger casings
• Mageau’s eyewitness description: a heavyset white male, 5’8″–5’10”, with a round face
• Telephone booth call from the killer claiming responsibility
  Rumor vs. Fact:
• Rumor: Darlene knew the killer.
• Fact: Police never confirmed this; it remains pure speculation.
  Impact:
  Mageau’s survival provided the first living description of the Zodiac — and it terrified the region. The killer now had a voice, a method, and confidence.

Lake Berryessa — September 27, 1969

Victims: Bryan Hartnell (survived), Cecelia Shepard (died days later)
Location: Napa County, California
The Crime:
A hooded man with the Zodiac symbol on his chest approached the couple on the lakeshore, tied them up, and stabbed them repeatedly. He then casually wrote the crime details — including the date of previous attacks — on Hartnell’s car door.
Evidence:

• Hartnell’s eyewitness testimony
• Handwritten message on the car
• A phone call reporting the crime
  Rumor vs. Fact:
• Rumor: The costume was never found.
• Fact: True — the hooded execution-style outfit vanished with the killer.
  Impact:
  This attack shattered assumptions. Zodiac wasn’t limited to guns. He could stalk, speak, and inflict intimate terror without hesitation.

Presidio Heights — October 11, 1969

Victim: Paul Stine (29)
Location: San Francisco, California
The Crime:
Stine, a cab driver, was shot in the head at point-blank range. Witnesses saw the killer wipe the cab interior and walk away — even passing police officers who mistakenly thought he was just a bystander.
Evidence:

• Bloody fingerprints on the cab
• Detailed witness descriptions
• A piece of Stine’s shirt mailed to newspapers
  Rumor vs. Fact:
• Rumor: The fingerprint matched a police officer.
• Fact: Debunked. The print has never matched any known suspect.
  Impact:
  This marked the Zodiac’s boldest move — a murder in the city, followed by a taunting letter that included proof only the killer could provide.

Letters, Codes, and Cryptic Threats

The Zodiac’s letters elevated him from killer to cultural nightmare.

What’s verified:

• He mailed at least 21 letters containing threats, ciphers, taunts, and demands.
• The famous 340 cipher was solved in 2020 — revealing no identity, only deranged philosophy.
• His handwriting and phrasing show a consistent psychological profile but no confirmed suspect.

What’s speculation:

• Claims that he had military or cryptography training.
• Theories connecting him to other unsolved murders.
• Internet-sleuth accusations against one suspect after another — none conclusive.

Separating Rumor from Reality

Fact:

• The Zodiac is responsible for at least five murders.
• Two victims survived his attacks.
• His taunting letters were real, authenticated, and devastating to law enforcement.

Rumor:

• That he stopped killing after 1969.
• That law enforcement secretly solved the case.
• That every cipher holds a hidden name or confession.

Truth:
The Zodiac case remains unsolved. And that may be exactly what he wanted — a legacy of fear that outlives his physical crimes.

The Human Impact

Zodiac didn’t just murder people — he hijacked a region’s sense of safety.

• Couples avoided secluded areas.
• Parents kept teens home.
• Police forces across counties formed special task forces.
• Survivors, families, and investigators endured decades of trauma, false hope, and dead-end leads.
  His ability to terrify whole communities was as powerful as the violence itself.

Your Turn, Crime Readers

The Zodiac Killer left clues, mistakes, signatures — and an ocean of unanswered questions.
What do YOU think?
Which Zodiac event or clue strikes you the most? Do you believe the killer was one of the known suspects, or someone we’ve never identified?
Share your theories in the comments. True crime thrives when sharp minds work together.

---

Affiliate Disclosure:
Some links in my articles may bring me a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support of my work here!

Never Flinch: A Novel (Hardcover)

The First Gentleman: A Thriller (Hardcover)