The unsolved disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley, the 23-year-old Virginia woman who vanished from the Rhapsody of the Seas on March 24, 1998, continues to twist in haunting new directions. Now, more than 27 years later, a private investigator says a $50,000 deal intended to bring her home may have collapsed at the hands of a man who claimed to know exactly where she was—and insisted she was still alive.

PI Jim Carey, who has worked with the Bradley family for decades, says he believes the man’s story. And the details he’s now revealing pull readers straight into the center of one of the most disturbing missing-person mysteries of the last half-century.

THE TIMELINE: WHAT REALLY HAPPENED TO AMY BRADLEY?

MARCH 21, 1998 – 5:30 AM – THE LAST VERIFIED SIGHTING

Amy’s father, Ron Bradley, leaves her sleeping on the balcony of their cabin aboard the Rhapsody of the Seas.
By 6:00 AM (March 21, 1998), she is gone. Only her sandals remain.

MARCH 21–24, 1998 – INCONSISTENCIES ONBOARD

In the days immediately following her disappearance:

• Multiple crew members give conflicting timelines.
• According to new information from Amy’s brother, Brad Bradley (shared November 2025), at least one staff member admitted that video footage of Amy was removed from ship tapes at the request of unidentified personnel.
• Witnesses Yellow (a crew member who knew Amy) and Oscar Alexander (Yellow’s roommate) report inconsistent early-morning timelines, claiming ship security knocked on their door between 3:00 AM and 4:00 AM (March 21, 1998)—before Amy was even reported missing.

MARCH 24–28, 1998 – THE COAST GUARD SEARCH

The Netherlands Antilles Coast Guard conducts a four-day search (March 24–28, 1998) of surrounding waters.
No body, no belongings, no trace.

Amy is legally declared dead in 2010, but the FBI keeps the investigation open with a $25,000 reward.

THE 1999 BREAKTHROUGH THAT COLLAPSED: THE $50,000 OFFER

In 1999, a year after Amy vanished, a police clerk in Curaçao contacts the Bradley family through investigator Jim Carey.

He claims:
“I’ve seen Amy. She’s alive.”

His price:
$50,000.

THE DEAL

According to Carey:

• The family agrees to pay.
• They work through Interpol, who transports a cashier’s check to Curaçao.
• When Interpol agents arrive, the clerk refuses the check.
• He demands cash, even though transporting $50,000 in currency was not allowed.

Then it gets worse.

THE BREAK-IN

Carey says the clerk broke into the Interpol agents’ hotel room (1999), ransacked it, and fled when he didn’t find cash.

Interpol left the island the next day.

“No one behaves like that unless they’re afraid,” Carey says. “And he kept saying—even 28 years later—that Amy is alive.”

THE 2024–2025 REINVESTIGATION

In 2024, Carey and two other investigators track down the same clerk.

They say he repeated the same story:

• “She’s alive. I saw her a couple years ago.”
• He repeated this 20 times, Carey says.
• He admits he lied about some things—but not this.

Carey’s conclusion in 2025:
“I believe him.”

NEW INFORMATION FROM BRAD BRADLEY – JULY–NOVEMBER 2025

With Netflix’s July 2025 release of Amy Bradley Is Missing, new leads explode.

OCTOBER 2025 – THOUSANDS OF TIPS

Brad says:

“There’s thousands and thousands of tips coming in… from everywhere.”

ALLEGED TAMPERING WITH FOOTAGE (March 1998)

Video editor Chris Fenwick claims crew asked him to remove footage showing Amy on the ship.

Brad adds that the person who gave that order never spoke to security—suggesting someone else was pulling strings.

THE 3–4 AM SECURITY VISIT (March 21, 1998)

Oscar Alexander, the roommate of “Yellow,” allegedly stated:

• Security knocked between 3–4 AM,
• Hours before anyone officially reported her missing.

Why were they looking for her?

THE POSSIBILITY SHE WAS KIDNAPPED

Amy’s ex-boyfriend Tom speaks publicly for the first time in 2025, recounting that:

• He and Brad flew to Curaçao in April 1998, two weeks after she vanished.
• During a drive, both swear they heard Amy scream “Brad!” from a passing vehicle.

This remains unverified, but both men insist it happened.

Tom also rejects rumors about Amy’s sexuality being a motive, confirming she was open and accepted by her family.

RUMOR VS. FACT

RUMOR: Amy secretly jumped or fell overboard.

FACT:

• No physical evidence supports this.
• The Coast Guard search (March 24–28, 1998) found nothing.
• No confirmed witnesses saw her fall.
• Her sandals were placed neatly, not in a way suggesting panic or struggle.

RUMOR: She ran away intentionally.

FACT:

• She left behind clothing, ID, money, shoes, cabin key, and personal items.
• Friends and family report zero signs she intended to disappear.

RUMOR: She was trafficked through Curaçao.

FACT:

• Multiple independent witnesses over 20+ years claim sightings.
• One witness (1999) recognized her from distinctive tattoos.
• A man claiming inside knowledge demanded $50,000—a credible red flag.
• But no verified photo or physical evidence has surfaced.

RUMOR: Cruise staff covered something up.

FACT:

• Witnesses claim footage was ordered removed.
• Staff gave conflicting timelines.
• A security knock before the disappearance was reported remains unexplained.

THE HUMAN IMPACT

Since March 21, 1998, the Bradley family has lived in a suspended nightmare:

• Decades of worldwide travel.
• Thousands of leads.
• A $50,000 ransom deal that could have changed everything.
• New investigators cycling in and out of the FBI, including one assigned in November 2025—who now must learn 27 years of case files from scratch.

Brad’s message today is heartbreaking:

“We operate every day like she’s out there waiting for us to save her.”

YOUR TURN: WHAT DO YOU THINK HAPPENED TO AMY BRADLEY?

Was she taken? Trafficked? Hidden? Or does the $50,000 informant hold the key?

Share your thoughts below. Real Crime Network readers often crack open angles that investigators miss.

---

Affiliate Disclosure:
Some links in my articles may bring me a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support of my work here!

Essante Organics – Your dream shop Guaranteed, Organic, Toxic Free, and pH Balanced Products. That’s It.