The quiet suburb of West Babylon was shattered on November 3 when a house party packed with nearly 100 teenagers exploded into chaos—ending with 15-year-old Liam Delemo bleeding to death on a front lawn while his parents desperately tried to save him. One week later, Suffolk County police made the arrest everyone had been waiting for: a 17-year-old Syosset boy, charged as an adult with second-degree murder. But behind the headlines lies a timeline of panic, unanswered questions, and a community still struggling to understand how a night of teenage drinking turned into a homicide scene.

TIMELINE OF THE CRIME

November 3, 2025 – 10:00 PM
Teenagers begin flooding into the home on Carlton Road in West Babylon, allegedly with permission from the 70-year-old homeowner, Bonnie Miranda, who allowed her grandson to host a party.

10:25 PM
A fight breaks out among the crowd of 90–100 teens. Witnesses later report a “chaotic swing of bodies” and “kids screaming and running.” In the middle of that fray, 15-year-old Liam Delemo is stabbed.

10:26–10:30 PM
Someone calls 911. Within minutes, Liam’s parents arrive at the scene—only to find their son on the ground, conscious but rapidly fading. His mother later said his final words to them were:
“I love you. I’m sorry.”

10:45 PM
Liam is transported to Good Samaritan Hospital in West Islip, where he is pronounced dead.

Following Week
Detectives work quietly, interviewing attendees, collecting digital evidence, and scouring video from nearby homes. But police publicly release no details about the motive or what exactly led them to the suspect.

November 10, 2025 – Arrest Announced
A 17-year-old male from Syosset is arrested and charged with second-degree murder. Due to his age, his name is withheld. He is arraigned in Central Islip.

WHAT EVIDENCE DO WE KNOW ABOUT?

While Suffolk County police are holding the investigative file tight, here is what is confirmed—or strongly suggested—from official statements and credible reporting:

Confirmed Evidence

• Witness statements from the party
  Police interviewed multiple teens who saw parts of the fight. Some gave conflicting accounts, which is common in chaotic crowd events.
• Forensic evidence from the scene
  Detectives have processed the area where Liam collapsed. Blood evidence would have been collected, though the knife itself has not been confirmed as recovered.
• Suspect’s proximity and involvement
  While authorities have not detailed the proof, the suspect was directly linked to the stabbing by investigators enough to justify a second-degree murder charge.

Evidence NOT Confirmed

• No motive has been released.
• No confirmation of video capturing the stabbing.
• No confirmation of whether the suspect confessed or denied involvement.
• No timeline of how quickly the suspect was identified.

In cases involving minors, investigators often withhold details to protect juveniles involved as both witnesses and suspects. But the secrecy here has fueled speculation.

RUMOR VS. FACT

RUMOR 1: “The stabbing was gang-related.”

FACT: Police have released zero statements indicating gang involvement. No evidence supports this claim.

RUMOR 2: “The homeowner hosted the party intentionally for underage drinking.”

FACT: Police did charge 70-year-old Bonnie Miranda under the social host law and with child endangerment—but Liam’s parents publicly stated they do not blame her.

RUMOR 3: “Multiple kids were armed.”

FACT: Only one stabbing injury occurred, and no police statement indicates multiple weapons.

RUMOR 4: “The fight began over a girl.”

FACT: The motive behind the altercation has not been released. Anything circulating online is speculation.

THE HUMAN IMPACT

Liam Delemo was just weeks from turning 16. Friends described him as loyal, protective, and always willing to help. His father told reporters outside the funeral home:

“He loved all of his friends… He would do anything for them.”

His parents arrived at the scene moments after their son was stabbed—something no parent should ever witness. Their pain has been magnified by the silence of the teens who saw what happened. Liam’s father pleaded:

“This whole, ‘If I tell on somebody I’m a rat’… that goes out the window. My son’s dead.”

The arrest brings a sliver of closure—but not answers. Not yet.

THE BOTTOM LINE

A 15-year-old is dead. A 17-year-old now faces adult murder charges. Dozens of teenagers are living with trauma from that night. And a community is left wondering how a normal weekend party spiraled into tragedy in seconds.

The investigation is still open. More details will come.
But the human cost is already permanent.

YOUR TURN — WHAT DO YOU THINK?

Was this a preventable tragedy?
Should the homeowner face harsher charges?
Are police withholding too much—or protecting the integrity of the case?

Share your thoughts in the comments. Your perspective matters.

---

Affiliate Disclosure:
Some links in my articles may bring me a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support of my work here!